'What Was More Important In Choosing A Successor Religion\r'

'Although, citation B and D withdraw try that godliness as still a slight pointor that was taken into amity. fount B is a historians summary of the howeverts skirt Lady Jane color in brief reign. It begins to project how towards the end of Edwards reign he and Northumberland were real aware that his switch would be his Catholic sister, bloody shame. They planned to alter the age in order to ‘secure Protestantism. ‘ This part of the get-go clearly shows how determined Edward and Northumberland were at retentiveness the protestant tower oer England.This is because they had pass Edwards reign converting the country to Protestantism and building up former under this trust and if this were thusly to be changed to universality then the main(prenominal) rival would be the loss of advocate for some, including Northumberland. In a way, the rea watchword religion was macrocosm considered everyplace authenticity is because Northumberland had convert Edwar d to do so. There is no c onceal the f issue that Edward would do most things that Northumberland would order him to so what would grab him from altering the chronological succession comport if that is what Northumberland wanted.If Protestantism were to continue as the belief religion then Northumberland loud be fit to keep his position of force and if this religion were to be continued with the rule of Lady Jane colourize then Northumberland powers would stomach increased due to the fact that his son was married to Jane grey-haired. Whereas in the second one-half of the ejaculate it says how bloody shame was decided as heir and done by the power of her genuineness. She was crowned alternate because she made it so there was ‘a much wider pull forward to genuineness and a careful escape of religious issues. People call forthed because she avoided religion, showing that is was non an influential aspect cause peck didnt have a great rival towards her wor ld a catholic, and because she based her appeal on the fact that she was legitimate because her get down was total heat octad, the people cared more for the descent of royal blood. The fact that this mention is pen by a historian is salutary to the comparison Of which was more essential, religion or authenticity, because hes able to give a over view of the thus farts without the influence of either twine compared to if the seeded player were to be written by someone of the time. overall this source shows how although religion whitethorn on been put into consideration ND may of been really in-chief(postnominal) to others, it doesnt stop that legitimacy became the final decider of who would be successor; sack a meetst that ‘in 1 542 and 1 558 religion was more important consideration then legitimacy in cave in the succession to the crown. ‘ root system D is as well as showing how both religion and legitimacy were used to decide a successor. theme D is written by a servant of the king of Spain from the courts deciding on the arrangements for Mays successor.Although its written by a break ones back I doubt there would be much bias because he is a servant of the King of Spain who as no interest in the succession and the fact that he allow for not gain anything from this due to the arrangements in his and Mars marriage contract. The source begins by saying how the Privy Council had to influence bloody shame to agree to Elizabeth as her successor because Mary did not want this to be the case seeing as Mary had converted England to Catholicism aft(prenominal) Edwards rule as a protestant and at present another protestant would be pose in rule causing her efforts to nonplus meaningless.However, she did agree but with the terms that Elizabeth leave alone: ‘maintain the Old religion as the Queen had restored it; and he other that she allow pay the Queens debts. ‘ Therefore, Elizabeth is chosen as successor completely due to the fact that she has the highest standing(a) of legitimacy but Mary does not want her efforts as Queen to be over looked and disregarded which is wherefore she wishes for Catholicism to be maintained. This agreement is carried out even though Mary necks that Elizabeth is most belike to break those promises which show that all Mary truly cares about is legitimacy.As long as the Tudor blood line continues in power, religion does not alter the weft of successor. Again, religion may be considered and important to some yet the decision of successor will always depend on their legitimacy because thats what everyone knows truly counts. Both of sources B and D show how religion may of been important to certain individuals but legitimacy would always over rule. The power of legitimacy is shown within sources A and C; Source A is from the third succession act written by Henry VIII with the permission of the Privy Council.It states how after Henry and Edwards death, then the thrown should pass to Mary and her heirs, then onto Elizabeth and her heirs if Mary were to die without any children. Religion is not mention once within this source because Henrys main concern was to provide the thrown with Tudor successors for old age to come. We can tell that religion plays no part with Henry because he will left the Catholic church building and give rised the Church of England just so he would be able to have control and pass himself a divorce from his first wife and another to come.His many wives also show his determination to provide heirs to the throne because he had 6 wives in order to create a son who would rule England after his death. Henry was so committed to qualification sure that the throne would continue with the Tudor name. Also due to this act being passed with the permission of the Privy Council shows that they too do not care about the religion someone has, as long as they fit the part of being swayer of England. No mention of religion and no conc ern towards what the future successors religious perceptiveness may be, the only thing that matters is who will be in control of England in the future.Now for the third time its going against the passe-partout statement. Source C is also going against religion being more important than astigmatic. It is a solvent to Marry earn claiming her right to the throne. The Privy Council are telltale(a) Mary that it is Jane Grey who is the just successor to the throne due to letters Edward wrote to begin with his death and that due to the divorce of her become and Henry VIII it causes Mary to be illegitimate.Legitimacy is used within this source to confirm the position of Lady Jane Grey and intermit the position of Mary. They use it to say that Jane Grey is clearly the right successor because she has a relation to Henry VIII, yet even though Mary is his daughter they choose to disregard her because of a succession act that called her illegitimate even though afterward on that succ ession act was over thrown by the third succession act.Even though religion isnt mentioned we know that this response has been written because Edward was desperate to have a protestant as his SUccessor which is why so much weight is put on Edwards ‘Great seal of England. ‘ The PRI,y Council know they have a very cut chance at making Jane Grey successor over Mary but they were willing to try. Yet in the sense of this source it heavily relies on legitimacy, even though Jane Grey isnt the true person to be next in line. The Privy Council have an agenda and purpose that they are act very hard to fulfill.However, we know that they in truth failed to place Lady Jane Grey as the rightful ruler of England because Mary was able to gain the support of the people who believed and knew she was the rightful successor due to her father being Henry VIII and Lady Jane Grey only being a cousin. This source shows how true legitimacy is much more powerful than the word of an existing Ki ng. Over all, there is without a doubt that betwixt 1542 and 1 558 elision was not more of an important consideration over legitimacy when it came to choosing a successor.\r\n'